Builder’s Notebook 4 min read

Say the Price Out Loud

The most expensive research a startup does is the research that never asks for money.

I have watched it happen many times over forty years of building companies in payments, crypto and AI, and I have done it myself more than once. A founder has an idea. They show it to people: friends, former colleagues, people at a conference, sometimes potential customers. The people are kind. They say it is interesting. They say they would definitely use it. They ask to be told the moment it launches.

The founder walks away hearing demand. What they actually collected was politeness.

A compliment costs nothing, so it proves nothing

There is a simple reason this keeps happening. A compliment costs the person giving it nothing. Saying "I would use that" requires no budget, no approval, no change to anyone's week. It is the social equivalent of nodding along, and most decent people will do it for almost any idea a friend is excited about.

That is not a flaw in the people. It is a flaw in the question. If you ask whether someone likes your idea, you are measuring their manners. If you want to measure their need, you have to ask for something that costs them.

The cleanest version of that is a price.

What changes when you say a number

The moment you say a number out loud, the conversation changes character. I have seen it happen in a sentence.

Polite interest turns into real questions. What exactly do I get? How long does it take to set up? Who supports it when it breaks? Those questions are the first honest information you have received, because they are the questions a buyer asks, not the questions a friend asks.

The objection you could not get anyone to voice finally comes out. Often it is something you never considered. They already have a tool that does most of this. Their budget renews at a different time of year. The person who would pay is not the person who would use it. You cannot fix an objection that nobody will say to your face, and nothing surfaces it like a price.

You learn who the buyer actually is. In the businesses I have built, the person who loved the demo was frequently not the person who signed. The enthusiast is often a user; the buyer is someone two levels up who has never seen the product and cares mostly about risk. You only meet that person when money enters the room.

And you find out whether the problem hurts enough to pay to make it stop. Plenty of problems are real and annoying and still not worth money to the people who have them. That is the most important thing to learn early, and the one we most want to avoid learning.

Why we put it off

If asking for money is such good research, why do so many of us delay it? I think there are two reasons, and neither is about strategy.

The first is that a no would hurt. Founders are, almost by definition, people who have tied their sense of themselves to an idea. Hearing "not at that price" or "not at all" feels like a verdict on us, not on a line of a spreadsheet.

The second is subtler. As long as we never ask, the idea can stay perfect. It exists in the place where every customer will eventually love it and every price will eventually be accepted. Asking for money drags it out of that place into the real world, where it has to compete with everything else a buyer could do with the same dollars. Some part of us would rather keep it safe.

I understand both reasons. I have felt both. But I have also learned what they cost. A no on day thirty is a gift: it is cheap, it is early, and it gives you time to change course. A no after two years of building is a funeral.

What I do now

My rule is simple and I try to hold to it even when I do not want to. Before we build much of anything, we say what it will cost, to a real buyer, and we ask them to commit something.

Money, if at all possible. A deposit, a pre-order, a paid pilot. When money is not yet realistic, something that still costs them: a signed letter of intent, a named person who will own the rollout, a date on their calendar that they will have to move other things to keep. The point is not the amount. The point is that the commitment is real enough to be uncomfortable to give.

I also try to say the price plainly. Not "we are thinking it might be somewhere around," and not a slide with three tiers and an asterisk. A number, said out loud, and then silence while they react. The silence is where you learn the most, and it is the hardest part to sit through.

Finally, I try to ask people who can actually say no. Friends cannot, not really. Former colleagues who like you cannot. The people whose answer counts are the ones with the budget and no reason to spare your feelings.

The respect in a price

There is one more thing I have come to believe about this, and it is not only tactical. Naming a price is a form of respect. It treats the other person as an adult who can weigh value and decide for themselves. It stops asking them to perform enthusiasm and starts asking them for a judgment.

Most people are relieved by that. They would rather tell you the truth than keep being polite. You just have to give them a question that makes the truth possible.

Say the price out loud. Early, plainly, and to someone who can say no.

← All essays

Read more from Alan

Join the reader list for new essays, book updates, and the first chapter of Image Bearers.

Join the Reader List